Review by Anton Spiridonov (smape.com)
Sony Ericcson W902 can be viewed as the first top-class Walkman handset released by Sony Ericsson in the recent years. The new gadget
borrows much from the W810i bestseller, offering a straight-out combination of music and camera features where neither aspect is neglected.
In some sense this phone could possibly be taken for a counterpart to C902, but we’d rather stay from such verdicts… for C902 was only nominally labeled Cyber-shot, but in real life its
camera capabilities weren’t at the maximum, which resulted in a more fashion-side public recognition, rather than as a pureblood
cameraphone; in other words, the high quality of assembly and diversity of materials, the fashionable design all outweighed the camera
strengths, so people mostly favored for C902 for its looks and not the camera itself. The W902 model comes with a 5 Mp auto-focusing camera
no worse than the one in C902, but at the same time
offers a formidable music functionality, - not only you get a high audio quality, but also a nice bundling and a lot of extra buttons to
maximize your music experience and the comfort of operation. Currently no other Walkman model is up to the level of functionality
established by W902.
Sony Ericsson W902 is taking a shift towards
an all-in-one functionality, able to challenge some of the strongest
Nokias present on the market. To be worthy of its claims, the product
has to be up to some of the highest standards in all aspects, ranging
from camera and connectivity to music and design (let’s say once more
W902 has a very impressive appearance). All of these strengths combined
produce a gadget which you aren’t likely to find a single compromise
about… This handset is likely to become a mass market bestseller, a
goal far out of the reach of W980i – the later has a
less popular form
factor and is exposed to a number of limitations in the different
departments of functionality. W902 offers a much better balance,
covering a vast audience.
Design and Ergonomics
The exterior design of the new handset only
arises positive emotions; Sony Ericsson are traditionally strong in
this aspect. A variety of materials and textures were put to work: the
frontal panel enjoys a glossy surface, the side and back pieces are
made from a black matte plastic; the battery bay cover is reinforced
with a grooved steel plate, sharing the pattern with a secondary steel
plate on the handset’s left side. The latter fact gives a sense of
asymmetry expanded only further by the use of semi-transparent side
buttons (serving as player controls) standing against the gilded volume
and camera buttons. The glossy front surface glitters in the sunlight
in a way looking like Sony Ericsson W980i.
Just as the rest of models from the higher
price brackets, w902 bears a strong accent on its image; the handset is
unusually good-looking and original. Judging by its positioning and
design, it hardly has any direct competitors. The same is true about
the W980i, these two top-ranking music phones look like two sisters.
Yet, W902 proves to be handier in practical use, offering a classical
candy-bar form factor and a powerful cam. The phone will be issued in
three base color variants. The Volcanic Black will become available
first, followed by the Earth Green and Wine Red. Only the color of the
side and back pieces is variable, the rest of surface retaining the
basic black color.
The shoot button and the volume controls are
of a golden color; these buttons are located on the right edge of the
handset, bordering the three transparent player control buttons on
either side. In the earlier music-focused models, the lack of dedicated
player buttons felt like a most disappointing thing, but the recent
Walkmans make a good use of this much awaited and handy addition
(W350i, W980i and W902). The button stay active
regardless of the
currently viewed menu, so you don’t have to get back to the player
application if you want to switch tracks when you’re in another menu.
The only element housed on the left edge is a
Fast-Port firmware slot accompanied by a 3.5 mm audio adapter and a
HPM-77 hi-end headset. The latter is probably the best plug-in headset
to have appeared so far as part of a cell phone’s bundling. It was
first featured in the sales package of W980i, and is going to start
selling as an independent product this autumn. A high quality and an
exquisite design combined, that’s what this piece of technology
actually is. The upper edge of the casing hosts the silver-colored
Walkman button, which is also used for engaging the Shake Control mode.
The keyboard of Sony Ericsson W902 is quite
convenient, comparable to that of W890i. The buttons are small in size
but have a very good feedback. They are made of a matte plastic
resistant to physical damage. The backlight is of a white color,
switching to red when the player is launched.
The back surface houses the polyphonic speaker
underneath. Its quality is pretty high yet it tends to get gagged when
the back panel faces a flat surface or the phone is put in a pocket.
The battery bay cover is manufactured from a thick solid piece of
plastic reinforced with a ribbed metal plate that adds some exquisite
feel. The camera unit is seated at the upper end of the casing, lacking
any special protection and, moreover, sunk below the surface. Hence
it’s a bit hard to get it properly cleaned prior to shooting, you have
to remove the battery cover in order to get to the lens. The former is
tightly fixed, but gradually a small play develops between the parts.
The phone is equipped with an M2 flash card slot with full support for
hot swapping. A 8 Gb flash card comes in the sales package. Just as
well you are getting an USB card reader for M2 Micro card compatibility
which looks a bit different from the one shipped with W910i.
Screen
Sony Ericsson W902 is equipped with a TFT
screen sporting a QVGA (320x240) resolution. It has a 2,2’’ diagonal
which isn’t much judging by the modern standard, the majority of
products from this class typically equipped with 2,4’’ screens (e.g.
Nokia N82, N79). The actual difference is minimal though, partially
compensated by a perfect screen quality. The maximum brightness level
is a bit too low, at times the backlight doesn’t feel strong enough.
This peculiarity is explained by Nokia’s desire to maximize the power
saving.

Nokia N78 / SE W902
As you see, the maximum brightness of the N79
screen is higher but the quality is superior in W902. Here we must make
an important point: the screen of Sony Ericsson W902 is protected with
a hardened glass which isn’t susceptible to scratches and wearing. The
glass is rather thick and a bit shaded, that’s another reason for the
screen to appear less bright. The screen of our W902 showed no signs of
damage while Nokia N78 got some nasty scratches.
A frontal cam used for video calls and a luminance sensor are
located above the screen. The latter automatically adjusts the
brightness level depending on the environmental lighting.
Battery
The model uses a standard BST-38, 930 mAh
battery, providing up to 9 hours of talktime or 400 hours of standby. A
normal duty cycle (amounting to about an hour of talktime, two hours of
listening to the music and camera work and an hour of menu browsing)
wastes a full battery charge in about three days, which is a fairly
good score, especially for a slim phone like that.
The Walkman series products all share the
traditional strength of a firmware power saving scheme which boosts the
battery life in the player mode. W902 isn’t an exception to the rule:
in Flight Mode, it can be playing music for a whole 26 hours before a
full battery charge fades down to zero. This is one of the most
remarkable scores on the market, only third to N85 and W980i. The
main rival to the device in question, Nokia N79, displays a comparable
result: 24 hours, just a bit less.
Sony Ericsson W902 Battery
| |
Nokia N79 |
Sony Ericsson W902 |
|
Normal duty
|
3 days
|
3 days
|
|
Multimedia cycle, video (3GP)
|
4:26
|
4:02
|
|
Multimedia cycle, audio (MP3)
|
23:35
|
26:16
|
Connectivity
Just like the rest of 3G-compatible models by
the company, a frontal cam for video calls is available. HSDPA is fully
supported, but the model lacks an infrared port. Expectedly, you get
Bluetooth 2.0 + EDR. It works just fine. We didn’t have any problems
with the wireless headsets either. The following profiles are
supported;
• Basic Imaging
• Dial-up Networking
• File Transfer
• Generic Access
• Generic Object Exchange
• Handsfree
• Headset
• HID
• JSR-82 Java API
• Object Push
• Personal Area Networking
• Serial Port
• Synchronization
• SyncML OBEX binding
• Audio/Video Remote Control
• Phonebook Access
The Flight Mode is in a way very much limited:
you have to keep the SIM card inserted even when the GSM unit is
switched off, otherwise the phone won’t let use certain features like
the player and camera after booting. Perhaps this is one of the biggest
disadvantages of all Sony Ericsson gadgets.
USB 2.0 is used for cable communication,
though the real speed is substantially lower than the presumed maximum,
only equaling to about 800 Kbytes per second. Mass Storage, PictBridge
and Modem connection types are supported.
The required mode is selectable from the
corresponding menu. Both the onboard memory and flash card storage were
accessible during a test Mass Storage connection. Phone-to-PC
synchronization is possible with the aid of the Sony Ericsson PC Suite
software which comes on a CD in the sales package. The only really
disappointing thing is the awkward location of the headset jack.
The integrated FM tuner supports the TrackID
service and RDS. An autosave feature is included into the radio
functionality, as well as a bookmark list enough for storing 20
favorite stations. The application interface is very user-friendly. The
signal quality stays on a high level, the same is true for sound
volume.
Java performance
Just as typically expected of a Sony Ericsson
product, the Java functionality enjoys an excellent implementation,
including support for 3D profiles and an opportunity to send midlets
over Bluetooth. The performance stands up to the respectable level of
K850i.
| |
Java performance |
|
|
Model
|
Sony Ericsson W902
|
Nokia N79
|
| Jbenchmark 1.0.1 Score
|
7353
|
3232
|
| Text
|
2303
|
891
|
| 2D Shapes
|
1812
|
900
|
| 3D Shapes
|
874
|
562
|
| Fill Rate
|
774
|
369
|
| Animation
|
1590
|
510
|
| Jbenchmark 2.0.1 Score
|
229
|
548
|
| Image Manipulations
|
257
|
244
|
| Text
|
563
|
595
|
| Sprites
|
473
|
470
|
| 3D Transform
|
171
|
1249
|
| User Interface
|
1314
|
576
|
| Jbenchmark 3D HQ
|
293
|
195
|
| Jbenchmark 3D LQ
|
305
|
380
|
| Triangles ps
|
30366
|
43343
|
| KTexels
|
1398
|
3254
|
| Jbenchmark HD Gaming Score
|
139 (4.6 fps)
|
166 (5.5 fps)
|
| Smooth triangles
|
32577
|
110145
|
| Textured triangles
|
28951
|
82240
|
| Fill rate, KTexels
|
1226
|
2287
|
User Interface
A variety of user themes are available, each
very different in its own way. The main menu, just as before, uses the
three standard viewmodes: icon grid, merry-go-round or a single large
icon per screen. The menus make an extensive use of animation and
transition effects including some nice pop-up windows. Sony Ericsson
products probably have even better looking menu graphics than the S40v6
Nokia ones, but the performance leaves much to be desired.
Preinstalled Software
The phone comes with three preinstalled games:
Need For Speed ProStreet, JewelQuest 2 (a logic puzzle) and the new FMX
II. We found them pretty entertaining.
The default software package is quite
standard, including applications like AccuWeather (weather forecast
viewer), StandbyWorld (a variety of clocks with customizable time zones
to be shown on the screen during standby; you can have several clocks
replacing one another in a loop, all running with different time zone
settings) and WalkMate, a pedometer program. The latter application
makes use of the onboard accelerometer, but the accuracy is a bit
disappointing. The Music Quiz program provides a plain ‘guess the tune’
entertainment using the tracks stored in the phone’s storage space. The
quicker you give the correct answers, the more points you score.
Google Maps is one of the standard components
of the A200 platform; a full-fledged GPS receiver stands for precise
hardware GPS navigation. Models lacking such a unit (like Z770i or
W890i) have to do the positioning by processing the acquired
coordinates of the closest carrier stations. Google Maps is free; the
program comes fully configured and has a number of extra settings in
addition to the standard functionality of the base version. You can
choose the preferred system of measures, to precise map scaling, add
chosen locations to your favorites list, customize the route
calculation routine and search by locations and bookmarks. The
application interface is rather handy; the downsides are a lack of
possibility to recalculate the route or save it. Nokia Maps 2.0
available to most existing smartphones offers a much better
functionality and comfort of operation, remaining the market's leading
solution.
Multimedia Features
The Media menu utilizes the same interface in
all A200-based products – it looks like a standard view window but with
a resemblance to Sony PSP. The motion sensor finds a real use here: it
switches the screen aspect depending on the physical position of the
handset. The following menu items are available: Photo, Music, Video
and Settings, names saying for themselves. The interface enjoys a very
pleasing graphics style; menu actions are animated, activating menu
items and entering the corresponding submenus works without the
slightest lag, thanks to the platform's high performance. The interface
design doesn't depend on a product's market positioning or model, even
the new UIQ-based smartphones sport the very same kind of interface –
Sony Ericsson's signature feature.
In addition to the rest of the features, the
player application works in a close cooperation with the onboard
accelerometer. You can easily switch tracks by shaking the phone in
specific fashion. On many occasions this proves a huge advantage. You
can perform three basic gestures standing for three actions: Next
Track, Previous Track and Random Track, which are correspondingly
activated by shaking the handset forward, backward or chaotically. The
trick is that you should keep the Walkman button pressed when doing so,
otherwise nothing will happen. Shake Control never misbehaved during
our test, which was the best thing we liked about it. Sony Ericsson
W902 also supports Shake Control volume adjustment, which is done by
leaning the handset forwards or backwards.
The player settings include looped and random
playback, sorting by performer, genre; enhanced stereo mode (which
doesn't give any perceptible advantage if turned on) Progressive track
rewinding is supported. The track data are shown in the player window
during playback. Visualization settings include displaying album cover
(though its size is too small) or one of the following options: Walkman
Lines, Album Lines, Inner twirl. There are two extra color schemes
available in addition to the default black one - orange and white,
though switching between them only affects the background and font
color. Nothing very impressive considering that latest Nokia phones
support full-blown player skins which look much more intriguing.
The playlist organization system is a very
smart feature; tracks can be added to a playlist either one by one or a
group (or all) of them with a single action (a checkbox is shown by the
title of each track). The set of equalizers varies depending on the
individual model. The non-music Z770i totally lacks any kind of an
equalizer while W890i has a whole six of them: from the typical Rock
and Pop to the brand Mega Bass mode. Unlike UIQ-based smartphones (e.g.
G700/G900, W960i), A200 devices lack the Auto Playlists functionality
which would normally include a rating system listing the latest added,
the last played and the most and least frequently played tracks, also
allowing for sorting by time (Time Machine)
Just like in Sony Ericsson W760i, W980i has a
Clear Audio Experience setting, comprising the following three
components: Clear Bass, Clear stereo and a quality handset found in the
bundling to go along with. The Clear Audio features constitute an
important part of the latest Walkman products by SE, effectively
improving the sounding the maximum sound volume. It should be
understood that all of the improvements are done on the software side
without any engagement of dedicated sound processing hardware
components. In this model, in a way similar to W980i, higher
frequencies don’t get muffled when you notch up the basses, the music
sound more natural and the equalizers exhibit a more pronounced
influence.
One of the most remarkable features of the
music player is the integrated SensMe system. As stated by the
manufacturers it allows to automatically pick music which best fits
your current mood. Now you can search for music and compose playlists
basing off the genre and tempo in addition to the traditional criteria
of album and performer. The track database is automatically transformed
into a graphical square matrix where each track represents a pixel
positioned at certain coordinates relative to the horizontal and
vertical axes, corresponding to a certain mood. You can easily select a
group of tracks sharing a common emotional impact.
The sorting is done on the PC using the Media
Manager application, which is used for setting the ‘mood’ of the
uploaded music. The user doesn’t have to specify these parameters
manually; the SenseMe application analyzes the tracks automatically.
Depending on the amount of data, it takes up to several minutes to
analyze the songs and add their mood tags to the database. This
function can be engaged in a forced mode, where all the music uploaded
to the phone is automatically analyzed and sorted according to the mood
once the uploading is over.
With the help of the navigation button, you
can easily browse between the spots dispersed across the matrix. Once
you’ve found a suitable track, you can inflate or deflate the
surrounding sphere; anything which falls into this scope will be added
to the playlist. As a result, you can grab a bunch of tracks sharing a
similar emotional charge in a matter of seconds. Multiple skeptics
complained about the limitedness of the TrackID service after its
launch – now you get a nice alternative.
The TrackID service enjoys a fair
implementation. Using it you can record a fragment from the currently
played song (on radio or in the player) and upload it to the web for
identification. If the sample is recognized as belonging to one of the
track stored in the database, the song title and performer name are
sent back in a message; all identified (and hence found in the
database) songs are available for purchase. The service should prove
interesting for a youth audience, especially combined with the FM tuner
functionality: an unfamiliar song can be ‘captured’, ‘probed ’ and
downloaded in a matter of minutes.
The bundled headset is actually one of the
best models currently available from the market. It’s a HPM-77 with a
supplied 3.5 mm adapter. The mp3 volume is high enough for most
situations but won’t be doing perfectly in a very noisy environment.
The sound quality is pretty good, above the average level of most SE
phones and on a level with the present-day leader W980i.
Camera
The camera unit is seated at the top of the
casing. The lens is protected with a mineralized glass to prevent
possible physical damage. Since this model isn’t a pureblood
cameraphone, there’s no specialized lens guard, though it uses the same
camera with Sony Ericsson C902. Such a marriage between Walkman and
Cyber-shot has been a long-expected arrival, in fact the previous music
phone with a cam standing up the Cyber-shot level of quality was W810i,
a successful product which was favored because of an impressive design
and vast features. W902 can be in a sense though of as its sequel. An
obvious continuity in design is traceable. The fans of W810i get an
excellent alternative sporting a more up-to-date feature list.
Right beside the camera lens you will see a
LED flash that can also support video shooting. The video quality is
all the same for all the latest models like K850i or G900. Also you can
use the flash as a flashlight by using a corresponding setting.
The camera is launched with a two-position
button located on the right edge of the casing. The volume controls
alternatively act as zoom controls in the camera mode. The screen
refresh rate in the viewfinder mode is quite high, the same is true for
the focusing and photo saving speeds. The screen quality itself is
pretty high, so it’s always comfortable for viewing your photos.
Let's now see in detail what the interface
looks like. It utilizes the landscape orientation, the difference from
K850i is minimal, for the concept proved to be very successful. The
right part of the screen is occupied by three small icons which serve
for switching between photo, video and gallery modes. The viewfinder
window contains a lot of indicators: the current resolution, the flash
status indicator, the macro mode status indicator, the number of shots
which will fit into the remaining space on the memory card or the
onboard storage, the image stabilization indicator, the geo-tagging
activation status indicator.
Pressing the joystick button left brings up a
traditional Cyber-shot setting menu. There are four shooting modes
available: Normal, Landscape , Frame and BestPic (the latter is a
variation of the more common serial shot function) Nine shots are taken
at a customizable rate between the moment of focusing and pressing the
shoot button.
There are three focusing modes available:
auto, macro and infinity (the latter means that the focusing is
effectively turned off). There’s no Face ID feature available. A total
of 6 scene presets (plus Auto) are available. That’s not too many but
will do in most situations. The list of available options runs as
follows:
• Auto
• Portait
• Landscape
• Twilight landscape
• Beach/snow
• Sports
• Document
During serial shooting, the maximum resolution
of an individual shot is degraded from 2592x1944 to 640x480. A series
may contain a total of 6, 9 or 15 frames at Normal or High quality. The
following resolutions are available:
• 2592x1944 (5M)
• 2048x1536 (3M)
• 1280x960(1.3M)
• 640x480 (0.3M)
The available special effects are rather
scarce in number: Sepia, Negative, Solarize and Black and White. Also,
the following extra features are available: timer, exposure meter, two
photo quality presets (Fine, Normal), shutter sound (selectable from 4
variants or no sound at all), image stabilizer. A total of 18 photo
frames are available.
The available white balance presets are Auto,
Daylight, Incandescent, Fluorescent and Cloudy, but somehow this model
doesn’t let you do any ISO adjustments – such a setting is simply
missing. The available geo-tagging option is a very interesting
addition, letting you tag your photos with a location ID. This option
is eventually becoming a standard feature of handsets outside the core
cameraphone segment. Image auto rotation is supported, so a photo will
always keep the original orientation, portrait or album.
Photo samples:
The quality of shots stays on a level with
C902 and K850i, which is a good score. Competitive solutions by Nokia
as well as the Motorola ZN5 are preferable in this sense, but on the
other hand W902 isn’t directly marketed as a pureblood cameraphone.
The Photo menu item allows to view the last
taken shot or the whole gallery, filter the images according to
user-defined tags, or access the podcast menu. Inside the photo folder
a number subfolders are found, organizing the content in a number of
categories: the camera gallery (in which the photos are grouped by
month), the latest taken photos, non-photo graphics and tagged photos.
The monthly camera gallery shows thumbnails for each individual photo,
a brief stats tab shows the total number and size of photos. Photo tags
are quite new to the A200 platform. Just like with Nokia S60 FP2, the
user is allowed to attach custom tags to his photos. This serves to be
able to sort the images by their assigned tags later, so your urban
life pictures won't ever get mixed with your Hawaii trip shots. Once a
'Hawaii' tag has been created, all photos associated with this tag will
become available through a separate folder titled 'Hawaii'. The X-Pict
Story is in fact a slideshow composer program which only has a few
basic settings. It won't let you set a custom time interval between the
frames, and the transition effects as well as background music are
hard-coded into the themes which are limited to four for the user to
choose from. Once a 'mood' is selected, the background music and frame
transition effect changes accordingly, these can't be customized in
ways other than switching to another preinstalled theme. You can't
create a custom user theme either.
The PhotoDJ image editor and Photo Fix are
expectedly included as part of the handset's imaging functionality. The
former allows post-processing a photo right after it was acquired; also
you can use it just to do some basic drawing like in MS Paint. It
includes the following options:
• Rotate,
• Auto Levels,
• Brightness,
• Gamma,
• Contrast,
• Red Eye Filter,
• Apply Effect (Negative, Cartoon, Frosted glass, Painting),
• Add Object (Frame, Clipart, Text)
The Photo Fix
function is a preinstalled set of filters which seek to improve the
quality of your photos, efficiently doing away with minor flaws. Once
it has been through the filter, you get a crisper and more
vivid-looking photo.
Editor's opinion
This handset surely ranks among the most
balanced solutions by Sony Ericsson and deserves some real attention.
As we have already mentioned, this model isn’t meant as a spin-off to
C902 but rather acts as a totally independent product which we are
inclined to view as preferable to the latter due to a number of
reasons. The variety of used materials and an ambitious design give a
ground for classifying it as a fashion model. The first thing your eyes
fall on is the asymmetrical construction and the metal plating, the
mineralized protective glass. At the same time, the functionality stays
above the level typical for most fashion phones. You get a whole 5 Mp
cam providing a fine shot quality and a dedicated block of player
controls. The audio quality is also better than you would normally
expect to get with a phone lacking a focus on the music capabilities.
The sales package of W902 stands up to the
device’s top class positioning. You get a 8 Gb flash card, an M2 Micro
USB card reader and a hi-end HPM-77 headset. The same treasure you
would get with a W980i, a model which is a natural alternative to the
W902. Both devices possess a fairly similar feature pack, the biggest
difference being the lack of opportunity for memory expansion with
W980i, which has its 8 Gb storage unit integrated into the chipset
instead of being a replaceable flash module. The price for the device
is going to revolve around RM2400-2600 (500-550 euros) in October, the same price
bracket occupied by Nokia N79 and the slightly less expensive Motorola
ZN5. It must be understood that Sony Ericsson W902 shouldn’t be viewed
as a hardcore music-profile solution, rather maintaining a fair balance
of various camera and music features. To your advantage, this doesn’t
stand for some sort of a compromise in every possible aspect, better
described as being an upper mid-end all-in-one device laying some
claims to the fashion field as well. For the first time in history a
music phone gets a camera of such power, let alone the generous
bundling. All in all, this model stands among some of the best
multimedia offers.